When BMW announced in 1997 that it was having to restrict supply to the UK market, this was an example of strategic ostensible demarketing.
- It was ostensible because it is clear that no rationing of these luxury cars happened: the company's sales kept rising from 60,000 cars back then to 180,000 in 2012.
- It was strategic because it was a decision made and announced by BMW itself.
- It was demarketing because the threat of restricting supply seems to have been made in order to boost sales.
 |
| Graphic from psdpond.com |
BMW, like Coca-Cola, Heinz, supermarkets and the music industry were happy to profit from the theory of psychological reactance, which predicts that when you take something away from people they only desire it more. This may be an accidental outcome (we could call this serendipitous marketing, and was what Coca-Cola claimed had happened), or it may be a clear choice (Kotler and Levy defined ostensible demarketing as "giving the appearance of demarketing" 1977).
It is almost impossible to find examples that conform to Kotler and Levy's definition: to do so the company must have admitted that their intention all along was to deceive the public. Coca-Cola, with sales and market share rising following demarketing, shrugged it off saying "We are not smart enough for that" (Clifford 2009). BMW said nothing but kept importing the cars and counting the money.
References
Clifford, Stephanie (2009), “Coca-Cola Deleting ‘Classic’ From Coke Label”,
Kotler, Philip and Sidney Levy (1971), “Demarketing, yes, demarketing”Harvard Business Review, November-December, pp. 74-80
A good example of ostensible demarketing is the British staple, Heinz Salad Cream. In 2000 the company pronounced the death sentence on this long-established brand, only to see its fortunes revived. Salad Cream had been on British dinner tables for nearly a century, but the former market leader had been overtaken by more fashionable rivals such as Hellmann's Mayonnaise.
Losing sales and market share, Heinz annouced that it was going to take the product off the market. But while in the case of Coca-Cola the consumer 'backlash' came when the product was withdrawn, Heinz was 'persuaded' to give their brand a stay of execution by the consumer campaign which followed from the announcement (Smithers 2010). Consumers seemed to have rediscovered their love for Salad Cream, and as happened with Coca-Cola, could not imagine life without this national treasure.
A new branding strategy swung into action (Richardson 2001) with the rising tide of consumer goodwill being tapped into with an exercise repositioning of Heinz Salad Cream for a younger audience, including a substantial price increase. Fast forward another decade and the brand's health seems to be secure: time for a brand extension - a new lemon and black pepper salad cream.
The level of detail in this rebranding (pricing, packaging, promotion, distribution) suggests that it had been thought through in advance, in other words that that withdrawal announcement created the appearance of demarketing, while in practice Heinz correctly anticipated the role of psychological reactance theory in re-awakening brand loyalty. This theory predicts that when your ability to enjoy something is withdrawn (or threatened) you will often come to appreciate it more.
References
Richardson, Belinda (2001), “Kitchen classic: salad cream”, The Daily Telegraph, 7 July